Skip to content
Rebe & Traube

True or Nonsense?

Is Darker Red Wine Automatically More Powerful?

How grape variety and skin contact shape a wine’s colour, and why a pale Spätburgunder can be wonderfully expressive.

1 min read

A glass of red wine against a white background
A red wine’s colour is easy to assess in the glass. Only a sip reveals how powerful it tastes.Rebe & Traube image library

The myth “The darker the red wine, the more powerful it is”

An almost opaque wine is poured. Everyone nods in awe: this must be a real heavyweight. The pale Spätburgunder beside it suddenly looks as though it still has some growing up to do.

Colour depends on factors including grape variety, contact with the skins and the wine’s development. It offers clues, but it is no substitute for tasting. Alcohol, acidity, tannin and body cannot be reliably judged by darkness alone. A pale wine can be exceptionally expressive, while a deeply coloured one can be pleasantly soft. Appearance and mouthfeel are connected, but they are not the same thing.

True or Nonsense?

Nonsense. Judging power by colour alone is like judging an orchestra by how black its concert clothes are.

Further Reading

Sources

All wine myths at a glance

Die Weinpost

Good wine. Good stories.