Skip to content
Rebe & Traube

True or Nonsense?

Does a Screw Cap Mean Cheap Wine?

What a closure tells you about a wine, and why screw caps have a place on fine bottles too.

1 min read

Bottle necks and closures in various colours against a white background
A closure alone cannot tell you the quality of a wine.gresei / Envato Elements

The myth “A screw cap means cheap wine”

The moment someone twists open a bottle of wine, an eyebrow rises at the other end of the table. No cork? Not even a little pop? Surely something is wrong. Yet the screw cap simply has the misfortune of doing its job without any theatre.

It seals the bottle reliably and is also used for fine wines. The right choice of closure depends, among other things, on the intended wine style and how the wine is expected to mature. It is not a quality rating. Natural cork has tradition and charm; a screw cap, meanwhile, occasionally saves you the hunt for a corkscrew in a holiday rental.

True or Nonsense?

Nonsense. A good wine does not need a ceremonial wrestling match to get it open.

Further Reading and Viewing

Sources

All wine myths at a glance

Die Weinpost

Good wine. Good stories.