Skip to content
Rebe & Traube

True or Nonsense?

Is an Open Bottle Enough to Let Wine Breathe?

How much air reaches wine in the bottle, and when a glass or a wide decanter can make a difference.

1 min read

Wide glass decanter containing red wine on a wooden block against a dark background
Wine has more contact with air in a wide decanter than in the narrow neck of an open bottle.Givaga / Envato Elements

The myth “An open bottle lets wine breathe just as well as a decanter”

The cork has been out for an hour. “The wine has had plenty of air now,” announces the host. In reality, it has mostly spent an hour standing around while the guests grew impatient.

In an upright bottle, the surface area where wine meets air is relatively small. A wide decanter or gentle swirling in the glass can allow considerably more exchange. Not every wine needs this treatment, though. Some are open and enjoyable straight away; others develop with a little air. The most useful way to decide is therefore to taste the wine, not check the kitchen clock.

True or Nonsense?

Nonsense. Pulling the cork initially means just that: the cork is out. After all, opening a window is not the same as going for a walk.

Further Reading

Sources

All wine myths at a glance

Die Weinpost

Good wine. Good stories.